The Pardoner’s tale is about three hard-partying fools who set about on a journey to defeat the fate of death. They came to this decision after observing a corpse being carried out to a grave. This tale is told by a pardoner, which was essentially a con artist who sold papal indulgences with the promise of eradication of sin, forgiveness, admission into heaven, etc.
The tale goes that the three fools swore an oath to defeat death once and for all. Once they do this, they embark on their journey and stumble upon an old man who greets them. They are sorrowful when the greet him, for death has not taken him. The fools tell the man about his quest, and he only instructs them about a place where they would surely find death, under a tree. The fools heed the instructions of the old man and make their way under the tree, where they find eight bushels of gold florins. Driven by avarice, they forget their oath completely and now have the opportunity to indulge themselves on a permanent basis.
The youngest of the group goes to town to steal some food and wine, while the other two devise a plan to kill him upon his return. So that they may keep a larger share of the gold. This went on successfully, but little did the other two men know that the food and wine had been poisoned, and so they perished. All of them died without any of them being able to make use of their fortune.
There are various ways we can interpret this, and all of them would make a certain degree of sense. First, we can agree upon the fact that the old man knew what was under the tree, and that he was knowingly an agent of death. The old man knew where death could be found, yet he himself hadn’t died even though he really wanted to. Coincidentally also, the old man found himself throughout the story complaining and talking about death. Even when the fools encounter him.
The old man then was not death itself, but rather an ironic encounter that played the role of death in instructing the fools to their demise. The old man though is not to blame, for it is the fools who carried on with their free will the decision to embark on this journey to “defeat” death. They knew that if they took this path, that they would surely die. The old man wasn’t the personification of death, the fools were. For they knew what was coming to them if they went under that tree, and did it anyway.
Lesson 170, Western Literature @zbelles